Ohh Mocking Jay.
I read this book two days ago and I'm torn. First of all, The Hunger Games and Catching Fire were both great novels. They were both well written, and really kept me guessing as I read them.
I thought Mocking Jay continued on this track, as I continued to be surprised by the plot.
That being said, this was definitely not the mind blowingly super awesome ending to the series that I expected.
********SPOILERS AHEAD! So don't continue reading if you don't want to know what happens!!*******
Basically, here are some problems I had with the third book in the trilogy:
1.
The love story. Now I have been on team Peeta since the first book. And then definitely after seeing the movie. Not only is he cute and a good person, but he's a total romantic and is so sweet to Katniss. I was seriously rooting for them both so I was stoked to find out that at the end they are together! I even loved the epilogue that gave us a happy glimpse into their future together, however brief. I was a little confused at how this all played out though. At one point in the book, when the crew is on a fake secret mission to kill Snow and are hiding in the cellar of the fur undie shop (yes, I know exactly what I just said there. It's a little weird), Katniss hears Gale tell Peeta, "Katniss will pick whoever she thinks she can't survive without." So basically I was waiting from that point on for Katniss to have some sort of epiphany about this silly love triangle, but she didn't until, like, the last 200 words, which is not what I expected. Also, it seems that it wasn't even her choice! All of a sudden, she is home in District 12's Victor Village, with Peeta planting Primrose bushes in her yard and Gale is in another district with some special important job so.... decision made? So anticlimactic.
2.
Character death and destruction. By this I do not mean that important characters died. I mean, sometimes that has to happen, but it was the way it was done. I felt more sorrow after Finnick died form being torn apart by scary lizard-human mutants in the sewers than when Prim died in the explosion. Prim's death just happened. Shocking? Yes. Sad? Not as much as I thought it would be. I knew Prim was going to die before I started reading the book because a friend accidentally spilled the beans (my fault really, for not finishing the last book in due time...) so maybe I just built it up in my head too much? That whole chase scene in the sewers was pretty good, and the characters that we were learning more about as the scene continued were killed off in some interesting ways. With every one of those deaths I was thinking, "Oh no! Shoot." because I was getting to know those characters. I think Prim coming out of no where, and then just dying so abruptly didn't have the same effect.
3.
Viewpoint. Part of what makes the book interesting is the fact that it's written in first person, so you learn things as the main character learns them. I can appreciate that, but I just wish the main character in Mocking Jay wasn't drugged up in the hospital or knocked out half the time! There were multiple times when Katniss was waking up, safely back in her hospital bed (or whatvever), and had to learn what happened from other people. It was annoying. Katniss should have been more present in the book, so that we could also be more present in the book.
4.
Katniss. Yes, I think that Katniss' character in this book was part of the problem. Maybe I'm just used to main characters kicking ass and taking names, but she was so weak in this book. Were there a few times that she stepped up to the plate? Yes, and I loved it. But overall I felt that she was even more whiney in this book than she was in the last. I especially hated the frequency with which she hid in the closet. Don't get me wrong, shit happened to her that there is no going back from and she definitely deserved a few of those pity parties she threw herself, but not THAT many.
Gale and her are in a fight? Closet. Haymitch calls her out on her silly love triangle? Closet. I mean....where was that strong, independent, clever, and sharp girl from District 12 we met in the first book? You know, the one who volunteered to DIE to save her sister? Where was that same girl that fuels the fire with her disobedience from the second book? It just felt like she tuckered out in the end.
5.
The realism. One thing about this book that I had a love/hate relationship with was the realism that Collins gave is in this book. In my opinion, Katniss acted as a girl of her age would most likely act in the face of so many devastating events to happen in a relatively short period of time. There were times that I appreciated that, and times that I was annoyed by it, like how often she hid in a closet, for example. I could appreciate the fact that both many people, both essential to the plot and not, died in this book because that's war. I could appreciate the fact that Katniss got injured and had a few meltdowns, because that's life. could even appreciate the fact that she didn't end up all rainbows and butterflies with the perfect life in the epilogue because who would be after what she went through. But I think the collective realistic portrayals in this book made for a very anticlimactic ending, which I am torn on weather that was a good or a bad thing for me.
Overall, I liked Mocking Jay, despite my five areas of displeasure. I think that perhaps Katniss and Peeta should have some how met at the hanging tree at the end, but mostly because that would have felt like the right thing, not because it would have made the story better....
Definitely not the best book in the series, but worth a read to find out firsthand what happens with the characters. The movie will be interesting I think. For now, here's an
article I found that will just have to hold us over until it comes out!
Opinions?